With regard to the book "Welcome to Sex", the Clsasification Office in their summary said: "g) The law does not allow Te Mana Whakaatu to direct that unrestricted books are labelled, such as occurs with films. If the law allowed, Te Mana Whakaatu would have labelled this book M . The M label would indicate that the book would be suitable for those 16 years and older but does not impose a legal restriction. Parents make choices about allowing their children much younger than 16 years to consume M-rated media.
h) Te Mana Whakaatu will send this decision to the representative bodies of libraries and booksellers with the invitation that they may make use of this classification to determine where and how they make this book available for readers."
Emma Thomas, who founded the support group Children of Transitioners as you mentioned, was also interviewed on the podcast "Gender: A Wider Lens" a few months ago. I found her story very interesting. Well worth a listen. https://youtu.be/vQRf5V98ibg?si=1QWmdZ-b6D-JgFuv
So, you used a book that was way too adult for a kid's portion of the library to move onto the unrelated topic of being transgender? And then you ramble on about cross-dressers. There's a big difference between being a cross dresser (usually heterosexual adult men who tend toward shyness) and a transgender person.
Are you as upset about the mutilation of newborns' who are born with "indeterminant genitals?" Why is a 15 year old girl old enough to have a baby (but not an abortion) but not old enough to know she's really a boy?
If a teen isn't old enough to determine their true gender/sex... then how is a newborn intersex child old enough to know their true gender/sex? Depression and suicidal tendencies are common among those who've been surgically altered according to their parents' or their doctor's preference, which do not necessarily line up with the intersex person's perception of self.
This is a newsletter so unrelated matters are presented with a divider and a headline to indicate they are separate topics. Intersex conditions are also a separate topic that we discussed in a previous substack.
And this means what in practical terms? I need to dig through your archives to know The Whole Story?
You may think that trans and intersex issues are unrelated, but they aren't. Even if you disapprove of trans people, fine. But both demographics are treated with disdain, have difficulties dating, unusually have a hard time feeling comfortable with medical professionals they don't know affirm them for who they are, and have high rates of depression. But ya know what? Not nearly as large a percentage of trans people regret transitioning. A lot of intersex people wish they'd been involved with the decision.
With regard to the book "Welcome to Sex", the Clsasification Office in their summary said: "g) The law does not allow Te Mana Whakaatu to direct that unrestricted books are labelled, such as occurs with films. If the law allowed, Te Mana Whakaatu would have labelled this book M . The M label would indicate that the book would be suitable for those 16 years and older but does not impose a legal restriction. Parents make choices about allowing their children much younger than 16 years to consume M-rated media.
h) Te Mana Whakaatu will send this decision to the representative bodies of libraries and booksellers with the invitation that they may make use of this classification to determine where and how they make this book available for readers."
Thanks for this reminder. We will add it to a future newsletter.
The illustrated charts, with their straightforward definitions of the players involved, are brilliant. Well done!
Emma Thomas, who founded the support group Children of Transitioners as you mentioned, was also interviewed on the podcast "Gender: A Wider Lens" a few months ago. I found her story very interesting. Well worth a listen. https://youtu.be/vQRf5V98ibg?si=1QWmdZ-b6D-JgFuv
So, you used a book that was way too adult for a kid's portion of the library to move onto the unrelated topic of being transgender? And then you ramble on about cross-dressers. There's a big difference between being a cross dresser (usually heterosexual adult men who tend toward shyness) and a transgender person.
Are you as upset about the mutilation of newborns' who are born with "indeterminant genitals?" Why is a 15 year old girl old enough to have a baby (but not an abortion) but not old enough to know she's really a boy?
If a teen isn't old enough to determine their true gender/sex... then how is a newborn intersex child old enough to know their true gender/sex? Depression and suicidal tendencies are common among those who've been surgically altered according to their parents' or their doctor's preference, which do not necessarily line up with the intersex person's perception of self.
This is a newsletter so unrelated matters are presented with a divider and a headline to indicate they are separate topics. Intersex conditions are also a separate topic that we discussed in a previous substack.
And this means what in practical terms? I need to dig through your archives to know The Whole Story?
You may think that trans and intersex issues are unrelated, but they aren't. Even if you disapprove of trans people, fine. But both demographics are treated with disdain, have difficulties dating, unusually have a hard time feeling comfortable with medical professionals they don't know affirm them for who they are, and have high rates of depression. But ya know what? Not nearly as large a percentage of trans people regret transitioning. A lot of intersex people wish they'd been involved with the decision.
https://open.substack.com/pub/resistgendereducation/p/the-intersex-red-herring?r=24091f&utm_medium=ios